Log In

Question about Formal and Informal Treatment

Spanish

Originais Teachy

Formal and Informal Treatment

Hard

(Originais Teachy 2024) - Question Hard of Spanish

During an international conference addressing the colonial history of Latin America, a group of student representatives from different Spanish-speaking countries meet with a panel of experts and specialists on the subject. One of the students, whose delegation is responsible for leading the discussion, must address the panelists in a formal tone and using the appropriate Spanish pronouns of address. However, while preparing his intervention, the student comes across a letter written centuries ago by a Spanish conquistador to an indigenous leader of the time. In this letter, the conquistador addresses the indigenous leader using descriptive language, ethnocentric perspectives, and a clear intention to impose his worldview. Based on the analysis of the historical document, the student must determine how the pronouns of address used by the conquistador reflect the asymmetric power between both cultures and what linguistic strategies could contribute to his speech to maintain the required formality in the current academic context without reproducing the dynamics of subordination present in the historical letter.
a.
To maintain formality in the intervention, the student should use the pronoun of address 'tu' when addressing the panelists, as it is a close and respectful form that does not imply a power relationship.
b.
The student could choose to address the panelists with third-person pronouns, such as 'él' or 'ellos', to maintain formality without implying a direct hierarchical relationship.
c.
In the conference, the student should use the pronoun of address 'vosotros' to address the panelists, as a way to reflect the respect and formality typical of the colonial period.
d.
In the current academic context, the student could use the pronoun of address 'ustedes' to address the panelists, thus avoiding reproducing the dynamics of subordination present in the historical letter, and complement with inclusive and respectful language that recognizes cultural diversity and equality of contributions.
e.
An appropriate strategy would be for the student to use pronouns of address that clearly distinguish the hierarchical position, such as 'mi señor' or 'mi señora', to emphasize respect and formality in the academic context.

Answer sheet:

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Curabitur id consequat justo. Cras pellentesque urna ante, eget gravida quam pretium ut. Praesent aliquam nibh faucibus ligula placerat, eget pulvinar velit gravida. Nam sollicitudin pretium elit a feugiat. Vestibulum pharetra, sem quis tempor volutpat, magna diam tincidunt enim, in ullamcorper tellus nibh vitae turpis. In egestas convallis ultrices.
Emoji eyes

Answer sheet

You need to be a registered teacher to view the answer sheet

Emoji eyes
Teachy logo

We reinvent teachers' lives with artificial intelligence

Instagram LogoLinkedIn LogoTwitter LogoYoutube Logo
BR flagUS flagES flagIN flagID flagPH flagVN flagID flagID flag
FR flagMY flagur flagja flagko flagde flagbn flagID flagID flagID flag

2023 - All rights reserved

Terms of UsePrivacy NoticeCookies Notice